{"schema_version":"alpha-governance-record-v2","alpha_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce","ontology_version":"alpha-governance-ontology-v1","as_of":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.417017+00:00","published_at":"2026-04-21T02:55:15.270549+00:00","section":"evidence","data":{"state":"PUBLISHED","evidence":[{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:c0a1919281b626ba847082619e6bc660de244d149c82470f8990f3882a9f5792","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","title":"Dollar Tree, Inc. director board source","identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_independence:2","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:3","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:4","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:5","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:6","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:9","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_independence:2","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:3","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:4","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:5","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:6","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:9"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:b320f57c18c073724c5cc96a6f275dce059014f8724434ad7142f24abd65ba90","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","title":"DLTR DEF 14A director slate","identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-02T07:01:04.665859+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_role:8","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:10","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_role:8","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:10"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:6ec7b5c764ecbb1560cf149e24482fb95fcb250193ff52a514c97ab236ae1a60","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_proxy","source_family":"sec","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","title":null,"identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2026-05-01","retrieved_at":"2026-05-01T15:50:02.991+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:role:2","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:role:2"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7ff25acc9aa81852e20e75a42e7f6ca772c144ab823116b381d15faf7c366b2b","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","title":"CSX DEF 14A director slate","identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:ai_ml_experience:1","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_role:8","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:12","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:cybersecurity_experience:13","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:executive_company:14","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:executive_title:15","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:technology_background:17","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:ai_ml_experience:1","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_role:8","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:12","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:cybersecurity_experience:13","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:executive_company:14","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:executive_title:15","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:technology_background:17"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:71735c59a372dd9d365f2f876259f9e94dfe6e766bdec357a8dca59adf63084f","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","title":null,"identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2026-03-30","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:role:1","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:role:1"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7a316d6111a16a006819e68f177d35fd362eb6a74a60a54f7d14a113f8f1345e","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","title":"Air Products and Chemicals, Inc. director board source","identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_independence:2","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:4","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_independence:2","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:4"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:1562a191400cae7f9f69543a714e4558640d4fbaca3a1824601cf6d095f8200f","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","title":"APD DEF 14A director slate","identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-11T12:26:33.737623+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_role:7","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:11","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_role:7","alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:11"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e05fb394e8fe46348d5aa2b41107700c6a816e70fd9e7f314ab216464b0dab12","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","title":null,"identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2025-12-11","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:role:3","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:role:3"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:bc5362dda218221f0bb2b3c968542f70429ce82dd0523a34b4530eaf784b73ed","aliases":[],"source_type":"company_page","source_family":"open_web","publisher":"Air Products and Chemicals, Inc.","url":"https://investors.airproducts.com/static-files/d92b511c-0fb6-4256-b782-1e69860572a4","title":"Investors","identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":null,"retrieved_at":"2026-05-04T19:30:10.28629+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"open_web","score":35,"source_family":"open_web","reasons":["Matched open_web source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:profile_webpage:16","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:profile_webpage:16"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:f7c47e5e3f8b6e2872f327fc28cc4e284920090ed52a3f30ae0807c6a530e87d","aliases":[],"source_type":"public_source","source_family":"sec","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","title":null,"identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:5","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:5"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:3bfde267711d9106b76aefab9e195b5d4c9e7c1fa04c5cfc17f486cb3aee0f59","aliases":[],"source_type":"public_source","source_family":"sec","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","title":null,"identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:6","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:6"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:45e9c0f7891aece12ff7df24c0afad57d3d90a8613a40032ec9a907acbb4a7b2","aliases":[],"source_type":"public_source","source_family":"sec","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","title":null,"identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:3","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:3"]}]},"claims":[{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:role:1","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:hasCurrentRole","object_id":"alpha:company:csx-corp","object_label":"CSX Corporation","object_source_name_forms":["CSX Corporation"],"value":"Vice Chair at CSX Corporation","claim_type":"professional_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:professional_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"professional_role","human_label":"Professional Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"role_category":"director"},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-03-30","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:25.991+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:71735c59a372dd9d365f2f876259f9e94dfe6e766bdec357a8dca59adf63084f","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":"2026-03-30","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-03-30","effective_from":"2026-03-30","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:25.991+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.92,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:role:2","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:hasCurrentRole","object_id":"alpha:company:dollar-tree-inc","object_label":"Dollar Tree","object_source_name_forms":["Dollar Tree"],"value":"Independent Director at Dollar Tree","claim_type":"professional_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:professional_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"professional_role","human_label":"Professional Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"role_category":"director"},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2022-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:25.991+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:6ec7b5c764ecbb1560cf149e24482fb95fcb250193ff52a514c97ab236ae1a60","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01","retrieved_at":"2026-05-01T15:50:02.991+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-05-01","effective_from":"2022-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:25.991+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.85,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:role:3","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:hasCurrentRole","object_id":"alpha:company:air-products-chemicals-inc","object_label":"Air Products","object_source_name_forms":["Air Products"],"value":"Director at Air Products","claim_type":"professional_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:professional_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"professional_role","human_label":"Professional Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"role_category":"director"},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:25.991+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e05fb394e8fe46348d5aa2b41107700c6a816e70fd9e7f314ab216464b0dab12","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","source_date":"2025-12-11","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2025-12-11","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:25.991+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.95,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:ai_ml_experience:1","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:ai_ml_experience","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"AI and ML experience: not identified in the cited filing","claim_type":"ai_ml_experience","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:ai_ml_experience","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"ai_ml_experience","human_label":"AI and ML experience","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":false,"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.223555+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7ff25acc9aa81852e20e75a42e7f6ca772c144ab823116b381d15faf7c366b2b","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"CSX DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.223555+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.72,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_independence:2","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:board_independence","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Independent director","claim_type":"board_independence","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:board_independence","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"board_independence","human_label":"Board independence","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":true,"corroboration_count":2,"source_claim_count":2,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:43.703973+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7a316d6111a16a006819e68f177d35fd362eb6a74a60a54f7d14a113f8f1345e","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Air Products and Chemicals, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:c0a1919281b626ba847082619e6bc660de244d149c82470f8990f3882a9f5792","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Dollar Tree, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:43.703973+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"corroborated","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.95,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:3","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:board_membership","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Serves on the board of Air Products","claim_type":"board_membership","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:board_membership","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"board_membership","human_label":"Board membership","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"name":"Air Products"},"corroboration_count":2,"source_claim_count":2,"valid_from":"2022-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-04-21T02:55:15.270549+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:45e9c0f7891aece12ff7df24c0afad57d3d90a8613a40032ec9a907acbb4a7b2","identity_scope":"representation_reference","source_type":"public_source","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:c0a1919281b626ba847082619e6bc660de244d149c82470f8990f3882a9f5792","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Dollar Tree, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":null,"effective_from":"2022-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:43.703973+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"corroborated","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":null,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:4","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:board_membership","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Serves on the board of Air Products and Chemicals, Inc.","claim_type":"board_membership","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:board_membership","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"board_membership","human_label":"Board membership","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"name":"Air Products and Chemicals, Inc.","ticker":"APD"},"corroboration_count":2,"source_claim_count":2,"valid_from":"2022-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:43.703973+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7a316d6111a16a006819e68f177d35fd362eb6a74a60a54f7d14a113f8f1345e","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Air Products and Chemicals, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:c0a1919281b626ba847082619e6bc660de244d149c82470f8990f3882a9f5792","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Dollar Tree, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2022-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:43.703973+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"corroborated","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.95,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:5","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:board_membership","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Serves on the board of CSX Corporation","claim_type":"board_membership","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:board_membership","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"board_membership","human_label":"Board membership","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"name":"CSX Corporation"},"corroboration_count":2,"source_claim_count":2,"valid_from":"2022-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-04-21T02:55:15.270549+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:f7c47e5e3f8b6e2872f327fc28cc4e284920090ed52a3f30ae0807c6a530e87d","identity_scope":"representation_reference","source_type":"public_source","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:c0a1919281b626ba847082619e6bc660de244d149c82470f8990f3882a9f5792","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Dollar Tree, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":null,"effective_from":"2022-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:43.703973+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"corroborated","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":null,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_membership:6","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:board_membership","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Serves on the board of Dollar Tree, Inc.","claim_type":"board_membership","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:board_membership","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"board_membership","human_label":"Board membership","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"name":"Dollar Tree, Inc.","ticker":"DLTR"},"corroboration_count":2,"source_claim_count":3,"valid_from":"2022-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:43.703973+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:c0a1919281b626ba847082619e6bc660de244d149c82470f8990f3882a9f5792","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Dollar Tree, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:3bfde267711d9106b76aefab9e195b5d4c9e7c1fa04c5cfc17f486cb3aee0f59","identity_scope":"representation_reference","source_type":"public_source","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2022-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:43.703973+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"corroborated","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.95,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_role:7","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:board_role","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Board role: Director","claim_type":"board_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:board_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"board_role","human_label":"Board role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"title":"Director"},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2025-12-11","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-11T12:26:33.798386+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:1562a191400cae7f9f69543a714e4558640d4fbaca3a1824601cf6d095f8200f","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"APD DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-11T12:26:33.737623+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2025-12-11","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-11T12:26:33.798386+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.92,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:board_role:8","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:board_role","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Board role: Vice Chair","claim_type":"board_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:board_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"board_role","human_label":"Board role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"title":"Vice Chair"},"corroboration_count":2,"source_claim_count":2,"valid_from":"2026-03-30","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-02T07:01:04.756704+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:b320f57c18c073724c5cc96a6f275dce059014f8724434ad7142f24abd65ba90","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"DLTR DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-02T07:01:04.665859+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7ff25acc9aa81852e20e75a42e7f6ca772c144ab823116b381d15faf7c366b2b","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"CSX DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-03-30","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.172192+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"corroborated","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.92,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:9","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:committee_assignments","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"No committee assignment disclosed in the cited filing","claim_type":"committee_assignments","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:committee_assignments","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"committee_assignments","human_label":"Committee assignments","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":[],"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:43.703973+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:c0a1919281b626ba847082619e6bc660de244d149c82470f8990f3882a9f5792","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Dollar Tree, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:43.703973+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.95,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:10","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:committee_assignments","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Committee assignments: Compensation, Finance, Nominating/Governance","claim_type":"committee_assignments","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:committee_assignments","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"committee_assignments","human_label":"Committee assignments","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":["Compensation","Finance","Nominating/Governance"],"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-05-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-02T07:01:04.777014+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:b320f57c18c073724c5cc96a6f275dce059014f8724434ad7142f24abd65ba90","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"DLTR DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-02T07:01:04.665859+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-05-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-02T07:01:04.777014+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:11","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:committee_assignments","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Committee assignments: Corporate Governance and Nominating, Management Development and Compensation","claim_type":"committee_assignments","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:committee_assignments","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"committee_assignments","human_label":"Committee assignments","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":["Corporate Governance and Nominating","Management Development and Compensation"],"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2025-12-11","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-11T12:26:33.81583+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:1562a191400cae7f9f69543a714e4558640d4fbaca3a1824601cf6d095f8200f","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"APD DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-11T12:26:33.737623+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2025-12-11","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-11T12:26:33.81583+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:committee_assignments:12","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:committee_assignments","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Committee assignments: Executive, Finance, Governance/Sustainability","claim_type":"committee_assignments","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:committee_assignments","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"committee_assignments","human_label":"Committee assignments","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":["Executive","Finance","Governance/Sustainability"],"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-03-30","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.204199+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7ff25acc9aa81852e20e75a42e7f6ca772c144ab823116b381d15faf7c366b2b","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"CSX DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-03-30","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.204199+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:cybersecurity_experience:13","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:cybersecurity_experience","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Cybersecurity experience: not identified in the cited filing","claim_type":"cybersecurity_experience","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:cybersecurity_experience","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"cybersecurity_experience","human_label":"Cybersecurity experience","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":false,"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.26954+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7ff25acc9aa81852e20e75a42e7f6ca772c144ab823116b381d15faf7c366b2b","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"CSX DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.26954+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.72,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:executive_company:14","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:executive_company","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Executive at Mantle Ridge LP","claim_type":"executive_company","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:executive_company","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"executive_company","human_label":"Executive company","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"name":"Mantle Ridge LP"},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.340218+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7ff25acc9aa81852e20e75a42e7f6ca772c144ab823116b381d15faf7c366b2b","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"CSX DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.340218+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.85,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:executive_title:15","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:executive_title","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Executive title: Founder and Chief Executive Officer","claim_type":"executive_title","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:executive_title","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"executive_title","human_label":"Executive title","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"title":"Founder and Chief Executive Officer"},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.323098+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7ff25acc9aa81852e20e75a42e7f6ca772c144ab823116b381d15faf7c366b2b","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"CSX DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.323098+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.85,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:profile_webpage:16","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:profile_webpage","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Air Products and Chemicals, Inc. profile/source page found for Paul C. Hilal: Investors","claim_type":"profile_webpage","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:ungoverned:profile_webpage","predicate_version":0,"machine_key":"profile_webpage","human_label":"Profile Webpage","governed_predicate":false,"machine_value":{"url":"https://investors.airproducts.com/static-files/d92b511c-0fb6-4256-b782-1e69860572a4","title":"Investors","source_name":"Air Products and Chemicals, Inc.","source_type":"company_page"},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-04T19:30:31.402129+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:bc5362dda218221f0bb2b3c968542f70429ce82dd0523a34b4530eaf784b73ed","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"company_page","title":"Investors","publisher":"Air Products and Chemicals, Inc.","url":"https://investors.airproducts.com/static-files/d92b511c-0fb6-4256-b782-1e69860572a4","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":"2026-05-04T19:30:10.28629+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":null,"effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-04T19:30:31.402129+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.82,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:paul-c-hilal:technology_background:17","subject_id":"alpha:person:paul-c-hilal","predicate":"alpha:technology_background","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Technology background: not identified in the cited filing","claim_type":"technology_background","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:technology_background","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"technology_background","human_label":"Technology background","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":false,"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.25079+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7ff25acc9aa81852e20e75a42e7f6ca772c144ab823116b381d15faf7c366b2b","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"CSX DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.25079+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.72,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"}],"evidence":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:c0a1919281b626ba847082619e6bc660de244d149c82470f8990f3882a9f5792","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Dollar Tree, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:b320f57c18c073724c5cc96a6f275dce059014f8724434ad7142f24abd65ba90","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"DLTR DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-02T07:01:04.665859+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:6ec7b5c764ecbb1560cf149e24482fb95fcb250193ff52a514c97ab236ae1a60","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":"2026-05-01","retrieved_at":"2026-05-01T15:50:02.991+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7ff25acc9aa81852e20e75a42e7f6ca772c144ab823116b381d15faf7c366b2b","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"CSX DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":"2026-03-30T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:71735c59a372dd9d365f2f876259f9e94dfe6e766bdec357a8dca59adf63084f","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":"2026-03-30","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:26.085951+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7a316d6111a16a006819e68f177d35fd362eb6a74a60a54f7d14a113f8f1345e","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Air Products and Chemicals, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:1562a191400cae7f9f69543a714e4558640d4fbaca3a1824601cf6d095f8200f","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"APD DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","source_date":"2025-12-11T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-11T12:26:33.737623+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e05fb394e8fe46348d5aa2b41107700c6a816e70fd9e7f314ab216464b0dab12","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","source_date":"2025-12-11","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:45.30941+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:bc5362dda218221f0bb2b3c968542f70429ce82dd0523a34b4530eaf784b73ed","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"company_page","title":"Investors","publisher":"Air Products and Chemicals, Inc.","url":"https://investors.airproducts.com/static-files/d92b511c-0fb6-4256-b782-1e69860572a4","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":"2026-05-04T19:30:10.28629+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:f7c47e5e3f8b6e2872f327fc28cc4e284920090ed52a3f30ae0807c6a530e87d","identity_scope":"representation_reference","source_type":"public_source","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/277948/000162828026021944/csx-20260326.htm","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:3bfde267711d9106b76aefab9e195b5d4c9e7c1fa04c5cfc17f486cb3aee0f59","identity_scope":"representation_reference","source_type":"public_source","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/935703/000110465926053500/tm261374-1_def14a.htm","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:45e9c0f7891aece12ff7df24c0afad57d3d90a8613a40032ec9a907acbb4a7b2","identity_scope":"representation_reference","source_type":"public_source","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2969/000130817925000643/apd-20251210.htm","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"coverage_state":"PUBLISHED","quality":{"schema_version":"alpha-record-quality-v2","overall":0.921,"status":"excellent","publication_readiness":"ready","dimensions":{"identity":1,"coverage":0.8,"freshness":1,"evidence_completeness":1,"source_authority":0.968,"cross_source_agreement":0.825,"temporal_completeness":0.667},"diagnostics":{"published_claims":20,"factual_claims":20,"claims_with_linked_evidence":20,"disputed_claims":0,"conflicts":0,"stale_claims":0,"stale_claim_ids":[],"temporal_claims":3,"temporal_claims_with_valid_from":2,"missing_coverage_sections":["ratings"],"missing_expected_claims":[]},"derivation":"deterministic_record_projection"},"publication":{"state":"PUBLISHED","published_at":"2026-04-21T02:55:15.270549+00:00","observed_at":"2026-10-16T22:56:35.060903+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T03:51:25.991+00:00","verified_at":null},"verification":{"schema_version":"alpha-verification-states-v1","state":"corroborated","identity_ownership":"unclaimed","assurance_level":null,"claim_state_counts":{"source_reported":14,"corroborated":6,"alpha_verified":0,"disputed":0,"superseded":0},"derivation":"claim_states+identity_ownership","summary":"At least one published claim is corroborated by two or more public sources. Profile ownership is unclaimed.","facets":[{"facet":"identity","state":"unclaimed"},{"facet":"evidence","state":"corroborated"},{"facet":"evaluation","state":"not_evaluated"},{"facet":"monitoring","state":null},{"facet":"authority","state":null},{"facet":"freshness","state":"current"}]},"rights":{"public_retrieval":"allowed","agent_retrieval":"allowed","redistribution":"not_granted","model_training":"not_granted","commercial_use":"not_specified","relationship_pathfinding":"not_granted","direct_contact":"not_granted"},"resource":{"uri":"alpha://person/paul-c-hilal/evidence","section":"evidence","href":"https://registry.alpha.ac/api/public/profiles/paul-c-hilal?format=record&section=evidence","media_type":"application/json","availability":"contract"},"limitations":["Only permissioned public claims and evidence are included.","Absence of a claim is not evidence that the underlying fact is false.","Public retrieval does not grant model-training or redistribution rights.","Private relationships and Council activity are excluded."]}